Illustrative example

How AI search decides which towns a service area business covers

A two-truck plumber based in Dublin, Ohio works in four towns. AI assistants only name the business where the web gives them evidence. Each column is the pile of proof for one town; the bottom row is how many of four assistants (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode) named the shop for "plumber in [town]."

Coverage evidence by town
Dublinhome base
Hilliard~12 jobs / month
Powell~6 jobs / month
Upper Arlington~8 jobs / month
Business Profile service areasUp to 20 cities or ZIPs, ~2 hrs drive
Listed
MissingNever added
Listed
Listed
Reviews that name the townThe customer's own words
41 reviewsmention Dublin
2 reviewsmention Hilliard
5 reviewsmention Powell
14 reviewsmention UA
Town page on the websiteReal jobs, prices, permit notes
Homepagenames Dublin
None
Templatedname-swapped copy
Real page3 jobs + price ranges
Directory listingsYelp, BBB, Angi, chamber
30 listingsshow "Dublin, OH"
0areas-served blank
0areas-served blank
3areas-served filled
Job photo captions"Tankless swap, Hilliard, Oct 2026"
Uncaptioned
Uncaptioned
Uncaptioned
9 captioned
Named in AI answers"plumber in [town]," 4 assistants
4 / 4named every time
0 / 4Hilliard shops + a franchise
1 / 4named once
3 / 4named most times
What a model can match to a town

Reads as nothing

"Proudly serving all of central Ohio and surrounding areas."
  • No town named, so nothing matches "plumber in Hilliard"
  • Templated city pages: same 400 words, town name swapped (Google's spam policy uses city doorway pages as an example)
  • Stock water-tower photo, no jobs, no prices

Reads as evidence

"We do water heater, drain, and repiping work in Dublin, Hilliard, Powell, and Upper Arlington, usually same-day for leaks."
  • Each town named in a sentence a model can lift whole
  • Town page built from real jobs: house type, the problem, what it cost
  • Permit notes from your own pulls, drive time, local reviews
The not-our-town test: 10 prompts x 4 assistants = 40 answers
Home town (2)
"plumber in Dublin, Ohio"
"emergency plumber open now in Dublin"
Weekly towns (4)
"plumber in Hilliard"
"water heater replacement Powell Ohio"
"drain cleaning Upper Arlington"
"repipe older house Hilliard"
Edge towns (2)
"plumber in Plain City"
"plumber in Lewis Center"
Control: not served (2)
"plumber in Lancaster, Ohio"
"plumber in Newark, Ohio"
Log for each answer: were you named, who was named instead, and what town the assistant says you're in. Named at home but skipped next door = an evidence gap. Named in a control town = something overstates your area.
Crave AI · crave-media.aiCounts are illustrative, not client data